Agreed. For better and worse, in 'take' shots a lot of the time for actors they don't get a say, which is sensible from the perspective it's work, but also kinda disappointing.
I worked a little in PA stuff in my 20s - some of the stuff the actors, even the 'day player' types, would learn like at a pro level and then absolutely nail just to get told they were doing another shot for like a close-up of the hands and stuff - you could see how pissed/heartbroken some them were - one woman, I won't say who because she's now well known, had taken like a 3-month crash course and actually learned how to play the piano - and then on-set the director told her "Oh don't worry we'll just add that in post, we didn't even tune this old thing."