I am no "Expert", but Yep definitely Refinished imo. Looks like I can see small scratches/sanding marks underneath the gloss, that's always a dead giveaway. There are a couple other things which make me believe refinish, like the back of them have been coated with some also and as you stated the High Gloss finish is wrong on those. By the response you got, Travis is either a ..... or a ....., well I will be nice
, and have no desire to speak with Travis either.