Kevin, yes that is a "fair" deal. Better even.......
All depends of the "conditions" aside from the gun itself, a "good" Woodsman box is in the area of $50-$100, the mags are around $30-40 each, so you have "icing" on your cake so to speak.
In some areas the shorter 4" barrels are more sought after ,thus "more". As said always, in an 'auction' it would go for more possibly as it only takes two people who want the same thing. Hope this helps.......... /forums/images/graemlins/wink.gif
Are you sure the barrel is 4-inches and not 4.5-inches? If 4-inches, someone has cut off half an inch, and the value of the gun will be greatly reduced.
Which model of Woodsman? Pre-War? (several Pre-War variations are possible) Second Model? (If a Second Model, are the grip adaptors present?) Third Model? (some minor Third Model variations are possible) The value of each version and the accouterments will be quite different. Much more information is needed.