I passed on a WWII brown shoulder holster for $40 yesterday...same problems.
I know the Audley's are authentic and popular, and I have one. But I cringe at the thought of how many triggerguard finishes have been worn off by people just pushing the gun over the latch. I'm very careful with mine, holstering and drawing it slowly with my finger pressing the latch down. Which means your finger is inside the triggerguard, a dangerous situation. They just seem unsafe and damaging to me.