I always carried HKS on the job, and still have them for all of my revolvers. I also have some speed strips that i carry from time to time. I like that you have to turn the knob to get the rounds to release. Early in my career I have seen other officers drop their push type loaders, and release rounds all over the gorund. The HKS there are no accidental release of the rounds. JMHO. I do use full moom clips for my 325 in .45ACP I really like them. It is fast to reload, and the rounds are secured.