[kenhwind]

We've had both, both are nice.
Overall about equal fit and finish Pietta vs Uberti.
The Uberti's seem to have better action timing then the Pietta.
The Pietta is closer to a Colt pattern then the Uberti, the Uberti being a bit larger.

My Uberti was the old Model frame with the so-called charcoal blue. It had the "3 clicks" firing pin safety and I also changed it out to the traditional "C-O-L-T"

My Pietta is a Cimarron "Frontier 44 WCF" I like it a bit more then the Uberti. Mine had too much cylinder free spin where the action was on half cock allowing the cylinder to float. I am not a fan of the coil spring behind the hand. I put a Smith Enterprise hand in it and it helped a lot. I didn't quite get it "perfect' but a major improvement, besides I'm a 1911 mechanic not a S.A.A. one, but I'm learning. My brother had two Pietta's, now has one, and the action on his are fine, his are Great Western II, "Alchemistas"

 

[kenhwind]

My friend has an all blued Uberti that looks oretty nice, and imo it would be a consideration over the funky looking case colors.

 

[kenhwind]

My Uberti is four click, replaced the "swiss safe" cylinder pin with a Colt made model. It came with both style's of base pin screws.
View attachment 758649

My Pietta is also a four click.
View attachment 758650

The Uberti I had, we gave it to the kids, it came with the thumbscrew as well as the normal set screw.