Colt Forum banner

What is this old Colt?

746 Views 8 Replies 4 Participants Last post by  DuWhat
I passed on this today because I knew enough to know I didn't know enough. It was advertised locally as an 1889 Navy but I don't think it is. Upon inspection I saw a serial number on the bottom of the grip frame but no other markings. From what I've read here these grips were for commercial model. When I mentioned this the seller said he thought it was a detective model. He was asking $300 but I think I could have gotten it for less. So, what say the more knowledgeable here?

See less See more
1 - 9 of 9 Posts
Sorry duplicate photo. Here's the other side
See less See more
It looks like a commercial Navy model.
The Navy Model didn't have locking notches on the outside of the cylinder.
If it's a US issue gun there'd be US stamps on the butt with the serial number, and a government inspectors stamp on the frame just above the cylinder release, usually R.A.C. for government inspector Renaldo A. Carr.

This looks like a commercial model with the original 3 1/2" barrel and hard rubber grips.
Thanks, DFW--what do you think it's worth--ballpark anyway? The grips are good but one corner has a small piece missing. I think the photo missed it. I'm guessing maybe $250 but I don't know how rare those 3" barrels are.
I saw that one myself and passed on it. I think the barrel was cut down.
DuWat--are you in the burg?
I have one like it, but with a proper 4.5" barrel... Definitely a 1889 Navy, like stated, civilian model. From the look of that second screw hole for the locking lever, it might be a late model. On the inside of the frame, is there a hole for a cylinder bolt - but no bolt? I have one of the last ones made, it's on a 1892 frame (hole for cylinder bolt with no bolt installed) but has a 1889 cylinder without the locking knotches. I bought mine for $150 bucks, but the lockup and timing needed work. Colt made around 31,000 of these, so if the serial is over 31000, it may be a sad 1892 that someone's thrown a 1889 cylinder on....
As I recall I think it was a 41.
DuWat--are you in the burg?

On the other side of the river.​
1 - 9 of 9 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.