Colt Forum banner

22 Peacemaker 4.4 and 4-3/4 comparison

4.1K views 10 replies 10 participants last post by  Coltalloy  
#1 · (Edited)
These little Colts are my favorite to collect. many collectors know that the short barrels are the most popular and it seems the shorter the barrel, the bigger the cost. There is a slight exception. Some may also know that the 4-3/4“ peacemaker 22 is much more rare than the 4.4” This also applies to the New Frontier 22 too. This is because Colt began 1971 making the short barrel length in 4-3/4”. At the end of 1971, Colt changed the short barrel length to 4.4” exactly, for the remainder of the Peacemaker/New Frontier production.
therefore, ALL 4-3/4” barreled Peacemaker and New Frontier 22’s should have a serial that dates it to the first year 1971 production. There are a few 4.4” made in 1971 after the change, so that length can date to any production year.
Also to note: when Colt made the barrel length change, the word didn’t exactly become set in stone to notate the slightly different barrel length on the box label. The 1971-1973 brown “lift top” boxes had end labels, and this label information was filled out with red ink pen by hand normally, and so some will be filled out as 4-3/4” instead of 4.4” , although the box will still be serialized to the shorter barreled gun.
if ever coming across one of these model guns and not sure of the exact barrel length, the easiest way to tell is the 4.4” length is slightly shorter and basically the barrel is flush with the end of the ejector rod housing, whereas the 4-3/4” extends slightly past, as seen in this picture with the 4-3/4” on top and 4.4” on the bottom.


 
#2 ·
Never owned a 4--" version. Strictly on appearance, I like the 4 3/4 better.
 
  • Like
Reactions: what would you say
#4 ·
When I first saw these particular guns, I thought they might be a refinish by a professional establishment like Turnbulls, because the colors are more vivid that later production year guns. Buckspen verified them for me and informed me that it’s very typical for 1971 /early production G series revolvers to have more vivid case colors and most early production years guns seem a bit more glossy/polished blued as well.
 
#6 · (Edited)
I got my first Peacemaker Buntline 22 in 2005 for 300.00 € which converts to about 330.00 $ and thought that it is a neat little gun with great case colors. In 2018 I got a Peacemaker 22 with 4.4 " barrel in near mint condition with the second cylinder and box. Somehow the collector in me woke up and now I have ten of these little guns from the G series, at least one of the Peacemaker 22 and New Frontier 22 models with 4.4, 6 and 7.5" barrels each but I never saw one with a 4-3/4" barrel here in Germany. I would love to find a Peacemaker 22 with the 4-3/4" barrel. For my G series guns I payed between 220.00 and 400.00 Euro here in Germany. It seems that German or European collectors don't love these guns so much, which keeps the prizes low.
 
#9 ·
In Don Wilkerson's book "Scouts, Peacemakers and New Frontiers in .22 Caliber, he has this to say:

"The late SKEETER SKELTON of SHOOTING TIMES magazine thought the revolver would be much more attractive if the barrel was shortened to the same length as the ejector housing.This would give the revolver the same appearance as the very popular model P revolver with a 4-3/4" barrel. He led the campaign to change the length in his monthly column HIPSHOTS. Colt agreed to his suggestion and the barrel was shortened to 4.4" in the later part of 1971. Production of 4-3/4" barrels was relatively low with only about 7236 Peacemakers and 4339 New Frontiers assembled. For Peacemakers we have 3064 single caliber revolvers 4172 dual caliber revolvers. For new Frontiers we have 2382 single caliber revolvers and 1956 dual caliber revolvers. As many of these early revolvers were immediately put to field use, the survival rate in collectable condition is quite low. Mint in the box, G series revolvers with 4-3/4" barrels are seldom found today."

Years ago I ran into (and bought) one of the mint in the box (unfired), dual caliber G series 4-3/4" New Frontiers. I wasn't looking for it and had no idea how scarce it was. If I remember correctly I think I paid $400 for it which I thought was a bit steep at the time but didn't care because it was such a beauty and a Colt!

Being one of the rarest of these I've wondered what the value of it is today but probably have no real way of finding out without selling it which I have no desire to do.

I have thought though that if Buckspen doesn't have one (which he probably does) that it is indeed rare.
 
#10 ·
Any of the 4 3/4 inch barreled PM22 or NF22 revolvers will command a premium in today's market, particularly if accompanied by the original box and paperwork. I really have not kept up with prices on these guns lately but when I was actively collecting them, it was not uncommon to see them priced in the $1200-$1500 range and sometimes higher.
It is interesting to note that the discontinuity of the actual barrel length and what was written on the box label continued for many years. Even the 1980's NF22 with short barrels were sometimes labeled as 4 3/4 inchers!
- Bruce in Ohio