Colt Forum banner

What Is Your CHEAPEST GUN You TRUST FULLY For CCW? (A Purposeful Question):

15K views 120 replies 73 participants last post by  ei8ht  
#1 · (Edited)
By "Cheapest" I mean it cost little. Better if you bought it new at this cheap price, but second hand would be OK if none new.
Usually we talk middle class or upper-middle price-wise on the Lounge for new guns and of course Collectibles can be very pricey

Why the question? I live on a street that divides a nice middle to upper class area of beautiful older,homes, late 19th to early 20th Century.
A short block to my right at the nearby corner is Hell. Huge upsurge in violent crime, incredible poverty, shootings at least a couple of times a week it seems. I wouldn't walk there with 5 Carry guns. So, I know both "sides of the street".

There scum, illegal gun sellers feast on teenage gangs, selling to all, a long way from West Side Story in result. There the woman, husband gone, stands by a lonely bus stop that is 35 min. coming, not 15 as scheduled, completely vulnerable, waiting to do her night shift at the drug store after already working 6 hrs that day. She could be the woman taking a walk with her young child months later seeing the child fall, shot dead by a mis-aimed round in a drive-by shooting. This seems to happen once a year; maybe it's every other, who cares.
So, who REALLY needs that self-defense gun: her, the old man walking at night - car impossible, any of them - or me.

It's an accepted statistic, crime in poor areas has not only the perps to commit them but most of the victims to die.
Few can afford guns; know anything about how to legally apply etc. even though they'd be approved.
So I thought it would be a change for once to discuss the cheapest guns that are still good for Self-Defense.
Mine would be a used Detective for $297, but few would know what a Detective was in the areas I speak of, they might pass that by if they did have $350 for a gun. I've heard Bersa are very good and reasonable, and Hi-Point has excellent reviews although I have laughed at them - my arrogance.

Last, before I began shooting (2007) my city outlawed all gun ranges. There was one in the midst of one of these neighborhoods. Gone. Replaced by those further away than the suburbs, half hour or more drive; few in these areas have cars or gas money if they do. So even if they get a gun legally, where can they practice, learn, take classes.? They can't.

If you lived in one of "those" areas, and knew what you know, what would you buy if you could scrape a little money up; based on what cheap but effective guns you have now?

Thanks for any interest.
 
#12 ·
I see a lot of ads now for that SCCY CPX-2. I wondered what the story was. That foreign? There's also a new Swiss semi-auto, or new here, I've just begun to see many ads for. Least from them it seems like a very good gun. But anything Swiss tends to be costly and well-made. Can't think of the name of the gun.
 
#4 · (Edited)
My entry is this about 1953 S&W M&P .38 special that I bought from a gunshop here exactly 10 years ago for $280`s.
It`s the one I pack the most knocking along the trails on our RZR here in Utah. Shot a deer with it about a year or two ago that I hit with our atv. I have many other now classic guns that I bought 40 to 50 years ago for less that are "worth" far more due to age. A woman sold it to the shop and said it was her fathers gun when he was a cop, I dont know where.
Reliable, accurate and cheap. Not exactly a collectors gun, I have many of those but this keeps "those" in good condition in my safe. This had goodyears on it and I replaced them with stags I had laying around. Its cheap, but I am proud of it and it gets carried the most in the boonies. Hell, I have a 2 1/2" nickel Python I paid a lot less for 45 years ago but I aint gonna pack it on the dusty trails when this beater will do.

 
#5 ·
Second to the smith M&P above I pack this .44 special a lot too. It started life as a Heavy Duty 38/44. I found a 44 special barrel at a gunshow off a model 21, (same gun except for caliber), had a gunsmith friend swap barrels and rechamber the cylinder to .44 special. It`s accurate and hits point of aim. I own a total of 7 various .44 specials, (favorite caliber) and this gets used the most of them. I probaby have at the most $250 to $300s in it but 30 years ago. This is the one gun that I just might get reblued someday. I like stag grips, blue fixed sighted guns. I would guess it`s a late 1930`s early 1940`s gun.
 
#7 ·
Do I get to show 3? This is a 3" model 36. It was made about 1970. I bought it about 10 years ago on line for around $275.
It was just advertised as in "Good" condition. When I got it, it looked brand new in the box and unfired with all paperwork. Has the old lightweight pencil barrel. Just what I wanted for CC. .38 special. With a pancake holster its nice and light to pack. I put Packs on it as they fit my hand better than the little round butt grips.

 
#29 ·
Do I get to show 3? This is a 3" model 36. It was made about 1970. I bought it about 10 years ago on line for around $275.
It was just advertised as in "Good" condition. When I got it, it looked brand new in the box and unfired with all paperwork. Has the old lightweight pencil barrel. Just what I wanted for CC. .38 special. With a pancake holster its nice and light to pack. I put Packs on it as they fit my hand better than the little round butt grips.

Love to have a 3" Detective. I see them on GB but too rich for me. Three-inchers have it all, really nice.
 
#8 ·
My lowest cost carry handgun is a Sig 250 in 9mm and one in .40 cal. I paid about $400 ea. for these two. My back-up pistol is a Ruger LCP that cost $250. Today, the Ruger LCP can be bought for $200 on sale.

Currently, I carry an H&K VP 9mm that was $525.
 
#10 ·
Cheapest, yes, but still totally reliable would be this Detective Special look alike From Rock Island Armory;





Really neat little guns for $225-$250 price range.

Cheapest Semi-auto would also be RIA. This 38Super 1911;



Bob
 
#18 ·
I recently picked up from a large gun shop a Colt Police Positive 4 inch in .38 S&W for under $200. A former police gun, most likely New York City, the gun shows handling wear and a chip in the grip, but has been fired very little and is mechanically tight. The gun was made in 1915. Police at that time seldom shot their guns. Similar condition Colt Police Positives, usually from the 1920s and 1930s can be found in the range of $250 to $350. The New York City police went from carrying the Colt Police Positive in .32 special to .38 S&W in 1907, which they carried until 1920 when they changed to the .38 special.
 
#20 · (Edited)
FEG Hi-Power clone I bought for just over 200 bucks new. I've used it in competition, as my go to defensive pistol for years. Here's a pic, bluing worn off the grip and still running strong. I upgraded to a C&S extended safety and had to replace the extractor once.



Surplus Makarovs were a VERY good choice for many years. I know a half dozen people that have CCWed them regularly.
 
#22 ·
Detective special - two of them that I use periodically -One is the newer shrouded ejector version and the other is the unshrouded vintage. Paid $300 for 1 and $350 for the other. In the newer one, I use 125 grain HPXTP Hornady bullets handloaded hot 38 spl.load . For the older one I use 148 grain hard cast lead wadcutters fairly hot 38 spl load. I use these loads in each because each shoot close to poa at 15 yards with those loads and the bullets penetrate real well.
Both guns are Not mint but still look real good and no rust anywhere.The newer one has really nice bluing -looks like a nice Python Royal blue finish.
 
#33 · (Edited)
I shoot Buffalo Bore Hard Cast Smokeless Wadcutters. Also pretty hot. Fact in summer I switch to another 38spl of theirs, think it was called the FBI Load:
a hollowed (not hollow point) soft lead. That because people have lighter clothes than our winters. The wadcutter penetrates at 16" to 18", possible pass-through a T-shirt, not a Parka.
 
#26 · (Edited)
My Kimber 3" .45 and my Sig 238. I also sometimes use my S&W M&P 340. It's super light and easy to carry but it kicks like a mule. In time of need I'm sure I won't feel the kick however. The Kimber pushes a grand but I don't feel that is that bad if your in a bind and want to make sure the gun fires. The last thing that I would want to think when the bad guy is shooting at me is why didn't I buy a better gun.
 
#28 ·
I paid $300 for my Python snubby...but that was over twenty years ago and it was from my brother. I don't remember why he wanted to sell it but I jumped on it without question.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gvf
#37 ·
The cheapest I used to carry was a Colt 1911 model 70. Since I bought it back in the early 1970's, it was only $200-$225. Both it and I got too heavy. Then I went to a $500 Armscor Citadel compact .45 auto--still too heavy.


I now carry a girlie-man gun. It's S & W M683 shrouded hammer Airweight 5 shot revolver in .38P. I think it cost me about $375 and tax. It came with two sets of rubber grips--one pink and one black. I put on the black set and hid the other set in my closet--never to come out! Purchased a cheap HKS speed loader for an extra 5 shots. Brushed aluminum and Stainless--low maintenance plus the drop dead dependability of a revolver.

Image


Image


Cheers